Recent Court Rulings

Resident's Daughter Can't Get Unit

March 6, 2012    

Facts: The daughter of a New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) resident, and the daughter's common-law husband, claimed succession rights to the unit after the resident died. NYCHA ruled that they weren't entitled to stay as remaining family members. The daughter appealed,...

Resident Didn't Disclose All Income

March 6, 2012    

Facts: A resident sued the local housing authority for terminating her Section 8 rent assistance. At the time she first applied for assistance, she had been receiving Minnesota Supplemental Assistance (MSA) payments. The resident didn't disclose her MSA income where required on her...

Housing Authority can Terminate Tenancy

March 6, 2012    

Facts: In April 2009, a resident received a notice that the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) was considering terminating her lease due to repeated late rent payments. After the resident failed to respond to the notice and a subsequent notice, the manager sent a notice advising the...

PHA Denied Resident Moving Voucher

February 2, 2012    

Facts: A resident sued the local housing authority (PHA) for allegedly violating her due process rights. She claimed that the PHA withheld permission for her to obtain new housing after she had been evicted from her previous unit, and denied her a hearing related to that permission.

PHA Not Required to Provide Special Meeting as Accommodation

February 2, 2012    

Facts: In 2004, a family applied to the local housing authority (PHA) for a Section 8 voucher. After completing the verification process, the family received a follow-up letter notifying them that they were scheduled to attend an orientation or briefing meeting. The letter notified them...

Owner Gave Resident Proper Notice to Vacate

January 2, 2012    

Facts: A resident signed a one-year lease to rent a unit designated for Section 8 housing. At the time of signing, the resident was required to sign an additional lease for a term of one year with the local housing authority. The lease set forth various rules and regulations that restrict...

Housing Authority Can Evict Resident for Drug-Related Activities

January 2, 2012    

Facts: A local housing authority filed a lawsuit to evict a resident for violating the terms of her lease and federal law due to two incidents of drug-related or criminal activity in her unit. The first incident occurred in November 2009 when officers saw a man standing outside the...

Owner May Be Liable for Discrimination Related to Renovation Work

January 2, 2012    

Facts: A disabled resident's immune system is unable to filter out toxic chemicals such as formaldehyde and asbestos. She sued the site owner and property management company for discrimination under the Fair Housing Act, claiming that they failed to make a reasonable accommodation for...

Daughter Denied Succession Rights to Resident's Unit

January 2, 2012    

Facts: A woman sought to reverse a determination by the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) denying her request for succession rights to her deceased mother's unit. The woman grew up in the building, moved out in 1998, and hasn't been listed as an occupant or tenant of the...

Sex Offender Not Allowed to Live in Unit

December 15, 2011    

Facts: A local housing authority terminated a resident's Section 8 rental assistance for violating the Section 8 requirement that all persons living in the unit must be approved by the housing authority. Specifically, the termination letter stated an unapproved person was "...

PHA Can Terminate Resident's Subsidy

December 15, 2011    

Facts: An Iowa resident sued to overturn a PHA's decision to terminate her Section 8 housing assistance based on her failure to report income. The resident challenged the PHA's policy of treating a failure to report each of her child's Social Security benefits as a separate...

Resident Not Liable for Son's Criminal Actions

December 15, 2011    

Facts: A resident's 18-year-old son was arrested and found guilty in municipal court of possession of marijuana on the local housing authority's property. Based on the arrest, the housing authority attempted to evict the resident for her son's drug-related activity.